The evolution of the law applicable to divorce with a foreign element: from traditional connecting factors to the modern concept of limited party autonomy – Serbian Private International Law Act in the light of Rome III Regulation

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.56461/rep280126.06.S

Keywords:

private international law, divorce, party autonomy, Rome III Regulation, Serbian Private International Law Act

Abstract

The paper analyses the evolution of the law applicable to divorce with a foreign element – from traditional connecting factors, such as nationality and domicile, to the modern concept of limited party autonomy, affirmed in European Union law through the Rome III Regulation. The focus of the paper is a comparative and normative analysis of the current Serbian Private International Law Act and the solutions provided by the Rome III Regulation, with particular reference to the Draft of the new Serbian Private International Law Act.

Starting from the premise that globalisation and increased mobility lead to a growing number of international marriages and, consequently, cross-border divorces, the author emphasises that determining the applicable law in such situations is one of the most complex issues in private international law. Marriage has traditionally been subject to strong state protection, which explains why national systems have long maintained a restrictive approach to recognising party autonomy as a connecting factor in family matters. In this context, the Rome III Regulation represents a significant step forward. It introduces limited party autonomy as the primary connecting factor for divorce, while in the absence of choice it provides for hierarchically ordered subsidiary connecting factors. The paper examines in detail the limitations imposed on party autonomy: the requirement of a connection between the chosen law and the marriage, time limits for concluding a choice-of-law agreement, and the conditions of substantive and formal validity. Particular attention is paid to the protection of the “weaker party” through the requirement of informed and genuine consent. The mechanisms of public policy, both prohibitive and permissive, are also analysed, as well as the exclusion of renvoi in line with the EU’s tendency towards the unification of conflict-of-laws rules and enhanced legal certainty.

By contrast, the current Serbian Private International Law Act does not recognise party autonomy as a connecting factor for divorce. It relies primarily on the spouses’ common nationality at the time the action is brought and, subsidiarily, on the cumulative application of the laws of their nationalities. Although coherent and progressive at the time of its adoption, this solution is now criticised for its rigidity and limited adaptability to contemporary social developments. Unlike EU law, Serbian private international law retains nationality as the primary connecting factor and allows for renvoi.

The paper argues that these differences stem from distinct conceptual approaches: EU law favours habitual residence as the lex personalis and recognises party autonomy, whereas Serbian legislation traditionally relies on nationality and a strong state role in family matters. Special attention is devoted to the Draft of the new Serbian Private International Law Act, which fully adopts the model of the Rome III Regulation. It introduces limited party autonomy, recognises habitual residence as the principal connecting factor, mirrors the rules on the validity of choice-of-law agreements, excludes renvoi, and incorporates the permissive public policy clause. This reform would enhance flexibility, legal certainty and compatibility with the European legal framework.

In conclusion, the author maintains that contemporary developments in private international law clearly support the recognition of party autonomy in determining the law applicable to divorce. Retaining traditional solutions in the current Serbian Private International Law Act appears normatively outdated. Introducing limited party autonomy, accompanied by appropriate safeguards, would establish a balanced system combining private autonomy with the protection of public interests and would represent a necessary step towards the modernisation of Serbian private international law in the field of cross-border divorce.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Fani Spalević, Faculty of Law, University of Belgrade

First year PhD student

References

Barlow, A. W v W (Nullity: Gender) and B v B (Validity of Marriage: Transsexual) – A new approach to transsexualism and a missed opportunity?, Child and Family Law Quarterly 13(2001)2, 225–241.

Beilfuss, G. „The Unification of Private International Law in Europe: A Success Story?”, in: Future of Family Property in Europe (eds. K. Boele-Woelki, J. Miles, J. M. Scherpe), Cambridge 2011, 320–340. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781839700156.017

Bordaš, B. Harmonizacija normi o razvodu braka sa stranim elementom u Srbiji sa pravilima o sukobu zakona i sukobu nadležnosti u EU, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Novom Sadu 43(2009)3, 75–97.

Bradley, D. „A Family Law for Europe? Sovereignty, Political Economy and Legitimation”, in: Perspectives for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe (ed. K. Boele-Woelki), Antwerp 2003, 65–104. https://doi.org/10.2202/1535-1653.1121

Cavers, D. Contemporary Conflicts of Law in American Perspectives, Recueil des Cours 130 (1970), 75–308.

Cvejić-Jančić, O. Brak i razvod između prošlosti i budućnosti, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Novom Sadu XLIII(2009)2, 63–88.

Čolović, V. Uredba Evropskog parlamenta i Saveta o primeni poboljšane saradnje u oblasti prava koje se primenjuje na razvod i pravno razdvajanje (br. 1259/2010 od 20. decembra 2010), Evropsko zakonodavstvo 10(2011)35-36, 31–41.

Dethloff, N. „Arguments for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe”, in: Perspectives for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe (ed. K. Boele-Woelki), Antwerp 2003, 37–64.

Dika, M., Knežević, G., Stojanović, S. Komentar Zakona o međunarodnom privatnom i procesnom pravu, Beograd 1991.

Draškić, M. Porodično pravo i prava deteta, Beograd 2011.

Đorđević, M., Jovanović, M. „Unifikacija ugovornog prava u Evropskoj uniji – kolizioni i materijalnopravni aspekti”, u: Usklađivanje poslovnog prava Srbije sa pravom Evropske unije (ur. V. Radović), Beograd 2013, 198–218.

Đorđević, S. Postupanje javnog beležnika prilikom zaključenja bračnog ugovora sa elementom inostranosti – nekoliko napomena iz ugla međunarodnog privatnog prava, Glasnik prava 15(2004)2, 23–38. https://doi.org/10.46793/GP.1502.23DJ

Đorđević, S., Meškić, Z. Međunarodno privatno pravo I – Opšti deo, Kragujevac 2016.

Fawcett, J., Carruthers, J. M. Cheshire, North & Fawcett – Private International Law, 14th edition, Oxford 2008. https://doi.org/10.1093/law/9780199284252.001.0001

Franzina, P. The Law Applicable to Divorce and Legal Separation under Regulation (EU) No. 1259/2010 of 20 December 2010, Cuadernos de Derecho Transnacional 3 (2011)2, 85–129.

Gray, J. Party Autonomy Under the New Brussels IIa (Recast) Regulation: Stalemates and Innovation, Utrecht Law Review 18(2022)1, 45–56. https://doi.org/10.36633/ulr.763

Hatfield, H. Private International Law Concepts in Divorce, American Journal of Family Law, 19(2005)2, 77–83.

Kruger, T. Rome III and Parties’ Choice, Familie & Recht, 2014. https://doi.org/10.5553/FenR/.000013

McEleavy, P. Harmonizing the Law Applicable to Divorce and Legal Separation – Enhanced Cooperation as the Way Forward?, International and Comparative Law Quarterly 59(2010)4, 1143–1158. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020589310000564

Medić Musa, I. Poboljšana suradnja – Quo vadis, Europa? Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu 62(2012)1-2, 257–288.

Michaels, R. „Globalisation and Law: Law Beyond the State“, in: Law and Society Theory (eds. R. Banakar, M. Travers), Hart, Oxford 2013, 287–303.

Muelders-Klein, M. T. „Towards a European Civil Code on Family Law? Ends and Means“, in: Perspectives for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe (ed. K. Boele-Woelki), Antwerp 2003, 105–117.

Novaković, U. Pravo na poštovanje porodičnog života, Beograd 2015.

Panov, S. Porodično pravo, Beograd 2011.

Pavić, V., Jovanović, M. „Evolucija principa uređivanja privatnopravnih odnosa sa elementom inostranosti u srpskim kodifikacijama međunarodnog privatnog prava”, u: Usklađivanje poslovnog prava Srbije sa pravom Evropske unije (ur. V. Radović), Beograd 2020, 430–456.

Pešić Jenaćković, D. Razvod braka: istorijsko-pravni, demografski i sociološki aspekti, Sociološki godišnjak (2018)13, 41–58. https://doi.org/10.5937/SocGod1813041P

Pfeiffer, M. Choice of Law in International Family and Succession Law, The Lawyer Quarterly 2(2012)4, 291–305.

Pintens, W. „Europeanisation of Family Law“, in: Perspectives for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe (ed. K. Boele-Woelki), Antwerp 2003, 3–33.

Provaznik, P. Renvoi as a Value-Laden Technique of Conflict of Laws, The Lawyer Quarterly 15(2025)1, 43–58.

Rogerson, P. Collier’s Conflict of Laws, 4th edition, Cambridge 2013. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139048798

Schwenzer, I. „Methodological Aspects of Harmonisation of Family Law”, in: Perspectives for the Unification and Harmonisation of Family Law in Europe (ed. K. Boele-Woelki), Antwerp 2003, 143–158.

Stanivuković, M., Živković, M. Međunarodno privatno pravo – Opšti deo, Beograd 2010.

Stikane, L. What Effect Does European Private International Law on Cross-border Divorce Have on National Family Laws and International Obligations of the Member States?, Athens Journal of Law 5(2019)4, 435–456. https://doi.org/10.30958/ajl.5-4-5

Stjepanović, B. Regulisanje međunarodnog razvoda braka i Uredba Rim III – Efekat na pozitivno porodično zakonodavstvo, Strani pravni život 63(2019)1, 79–90. https://doi.org/10.5937/spz63-20534

Šimović, I., Ćurić, I. Europska unija i obiteljsko pravo: međunarodnoprivatnopravni, procesnopravni i materijalnopravni aspekti, Ljetopis socijalnog rada 22(2015)2, 163–189. https://doi.org/10.3935/ljsr.v22i2.87

Torga, M. Party Autonomy of the Spouses under the Rome III Regulation in Estonia – Can Private International Law Change Substantive Law?, Netherlands Journal on Private International Law 12(2012)4, 67–91.

Varadi, T., Bordaš, B., Knežević, G., Pavić, V. Međunarodno privatno pravo, Beograd 2008.

Wills, M. M. Conflicts of Law in Divorce Litigation: A Looking-Glass World?, Campbell Law Review 10(1987)1, 67–91.

Živković, M. Osvrt na neka pitanja srpskog međunarodnog privatnog prava, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Nišu (2020)86, 59–74. https://doi.org/10.5937/zrpfn0-24464

Internet izvori

Tekst Rim III Regulative na jezicima država učesnica: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/HR/ALL/?uri=celex:32010R1259, posećeno 31. 1. 2026.

Tekst Nacrta novog Zakona o međunarodnom privatnom pravu: https://www.prafak.ni.ac.rs/files/Nacrt-ZMPP-Ministarstvo.pdf, posećeno 14. 2. 2026.

Pravni izvori

Uredba Evropskog parlamenta br. 593/2008 od 17. juna 2008. o pravu koje se primjenjuje na ugovorne obaveze.

Uredba Evropskog parlamenta br. 864/2007 od 11. jula 2007. o pravu koje se primjenjuje na vanugovorne obaveze.

Uredba Evropskog parlamenta i Saveta o primeni poboljšane saradnje br. 1259/2010 od 20. decembra 2010. godine. u oblasti prava koje se primenjuje na razvod i zakonsku rastavu.

Uredba (EU) br. 2019/1111 od 25. juna 2019. godine o nadležnosti, priznavanju i izvršenju odluka u bračnim stvarima i stvarima roditeljske odgovornosti, kao i o međunarodnoj otmici dece.

Uredba (EU) br. 650/2012 od 4. jula 2012. o nadležnosti, merodavnom pravu, priznanju i izvršenju odluka i prihvatanju i izvršavanju javnih isprava u naslednim stvarima i o uspostavljanju Evropske potvrde o nasleđivanju.

Uredba (EU) br. 4/2009 od 18. decembra 2008. godine o nadležnosti, merodavnom pravu, priznanju i izvršenju odluka i saradnji u pitanjima koja se odnose na obaveze izdržavanja.

Zakon o rešavanju sukoba zakona sa propisima drugih zemalja, Službeni list SFRJ, br. 43/82 i 72/82 - ispr., Službeni list SRJ, br. 46/96 i Službeni glasnik RS, br. 46/2006 - dr. zakon.

Sudske odluke

Odluka Visokog suda Engleske i Velsa (Velika Britanija), Marinos v. Marinos od 3. septembra 2007.

Odluka Visokog suda Engleske i Velsa (Velika Britanija), MacMillan Inc v Bishopgate Investment Trust Plc od 2. novembra 1995.

Odluka Doma lordova (Velika Britanija), Bellinger v Bellinger od 10. aprila 2003.

Odluka Suda pravde Evropske unije, Anna Herrero Romeu v European Commission od 25. oktobra 2005.

Odluka Suda pravde Evropske unije, Pedro Magdalena Fernández v Commission of the European Communities od 28. septembra 1993.

Downloads

Published

2026-05-25