Denial of the Right to Contact in the Case-Law of the European Court of Human Rights
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.56461/rep280226.01.PKeywords:
right to contact, family life, positive obligations of the State, best interests of the child, European Court of Human RightsAbstract
Maintaining personal relations between parents and children, as an integral element of the right to respect for family life, imposes on States, in addition to an obligation to refrain from unjustified interference, a positive obligation to take appropriate measures to preserve and facilitate those relations. The denial or restriction of the right to contact may be justified where it is based on relevant and sufficient reasons and aimed at protecting the best interests of the child, provided that a fair balance is maintained between the interests of the child and those of the parent.
This article analyses the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights concerning the denial of a parent’s right to contact with a child under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. It examines the circumstances that may justify such a measure and the criteria relevant to assessing its justification, with particular regard to the best interests of the child, the decision-making process, the necessity and proportionality of the measure, and the possibility of less restrictive measures. Particular attention is also given to factual denial of contact, including situations in which contact is formally recognized but is not effectively exercised because the competent authorities have failed to take measures that could reasonably be expected in the circumstances of the case. In this context, the article considers the timeliness of the authorities’ action, the enforcement of contact decisions and the passage of time. The analysis shows that the admissibility of denying contact cannot be determined solely by the existence of reasons for restricting it. It also depends on the manner in which the national authorities assessed the relevant circumstances, the proportionality of the measure and its duration, and the steps taken to preserve or, where appropriate, re-establish the relationship between the parent and the child. The case-law of the Court thus demonstrates that the boundary between a justified restriction of contact and a violation of the right to respect for family life depends not only on the reasons underlying the measure, but also on the manner in which it is determined, maintained and implemented.
The analysis shows that the admissibility of denying contact cannot be determined solely by the existence of reasons for restricting it. It also depends on the manner in which the national authorities assessed the relevant circumstances, the proportionality of the measure and its duration, and the steps taken to preserve or, where appropriate, re-establish the relationship between the parent and the child. The case-law of the Court therefore draws the boundary between a justified restriction of contact and a violation of the right to respect for family life through a comprehensive assessment of the circumstances of each case. Ultimately, the admissibility of denying parental contact under Article 8 turns on whether, in the circumstances of the particular case, such a measure can be regarded as genuinely necessary for the protection of the child’s best interests while preserving the essence of family life.
Downloads
References
Choudhry Sh. “Domestic Violence, Contact, and the ECHR”, in: Law and Childhood Studies: Current Legal Issues, Volume 14 (ed. M. Freeman), Oxford University Press, 2012, 339–356. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199652501.003.0020
Daly A. Children, Autonomy and the Courts: Beyond the Right to be Heard, Brill/Nijhoff, Leiden–Boston 2018. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004355828
Guide on Article 8 of the Convention – Right to respect for private and family life, home and correspondence, Council of Europe/European Court of Human Rights, 2026. Last update: 28.02.2026. https://ks.echr.coe.int/, posećeno: 5. 9. 2026.
Kilkelly U. Protecting Children’s Rights under the ECHR: The Role of Positive Obligations, Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 61(2010)3, 245–261. https://doi.org/10.53386/nilq.v61i3.453
Koivula T. What makes a father: Differentiation of unmarried and divorced fathers in the context of custody under the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 38(2024)1, ebae002. https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/ebae002
Lingaas C. Domestic Violence in Child Protection Cases before the European Court of Human Rights: Double Victimisation of Abused Parents?, Nordic Journal of Human Rights 38(2020)2, 122–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/18918131.2020.1777771
Merckx E. “The ECtHR on Parental Authority and Contact after Separation: Towards a More Child-Centred Perspective?”, in: European Yearbook on Human Rights 2020 (eds. P. Czech et al.), Intersentia, 2020, 97–134. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781839701139.007
Rajska D. Parent-Child Relationship Cases Before the ECtHR, SocioEconomic Challenges 4(2020)1, 36–64. http://doi.org/10.21272/sec.4(1).36-64.2020
Rešetar B., Emery E.R. Children’s Rights in European Legal Proceedings: Why Are Family Practices So Different from Legal Theories?, Family Court Review 46(2008)1, 65–77. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-1617.2007.00193.x
Vertommen E. “Balancing the Rights of Parent and Child in Case of Non-Compliance with Contact Arrangements: A Case Law Analysis”, in: Plurality and Diversity of Family Relations in Europe (eds. K. Boele-Woelki, D. Martiny), Intersentia, 2019, 175–202. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781780689111.009
Pravni izvori
Zakon o ratifikaciji Evropske konvencije za zaštitu ljudskih prava i osnovnih sloboda, Službeni list SCG – Međunarodni ugovori, br. 9/2003, 5/2005 i 7/2005 – ispr. i Službeni glasnik RS – Međunarodni ugovori, br. 12/2010 i 10/2015.
Praksa Evropskog suda za ljudska prava
Diamante and Pelliccioni v. San Marino, predstavka br. 32250/08, 27. 9. 2011.
Hokkanen v. Finland, predstavka br. 19823/92, 23.9. 1994.
Hokkanen v. Finland, predstavka br. 19823/92, 23.9.1994.
Ignaccolo-Zenide v. Romania, predstavka br. 31679/96, 25.01.2000.
Elsholz v. Germany, predstavka br. 25735/94, 13.7. 2000.
Elsholz v. Germany, predstavka br. 25735/94, 13.7.2000.
Kutzner protiv Nemačke, predstavka br. 46544/99, 26.02.2002.
Sahin v. Germany, predstavka br. 30943/96, 8. 7. 2003.
Sommerfeld v. Germany, predstavka br. 31871/96, 8. 7. 2003.
Heidemann v. Germany, no. 9732/10,17.5.2011.
Vojnity v. Hungary, predstavka br. 29617/07,12.02.2013.
Prizzia v. Hungary, predstavka br. 20255/12, 11.6. 2013.
Buchleither v. Germany, predstavka br. 20106/13, 28.04.2016.
K.B. and Others v. Croatia, predstavka br. 36216/13, 14.3.2017.
Vyshnyakov v. Ukraine, predstavka br. 25612/12, 24.7.2018.
Fröhlich v. Germany, predstavka br.16112/15, 26.7.2018.
Jansen v. Norway, predstavka br. 2822/16, 6.9. 2018.
Kramer v. Croatia, predstavka br. 11922/16, 26.9.2019.
Popadić v. Serbia, predstavka br. 7833/12, 20.9. 2022.
I.M. and Others v. Italy, predstavka br. 25426/20, 10.11.2022.


